Do you want a 'citizen's pension'?
Courtesy of Money Telegraph (Filed: 15/12/2004)
Emma Simon looks at an idea for a new, flat-rate
retirement wage for all and asks whether Westminster will ever
adopt it
What is a citizen's pension?
The idea, first mooted by the Liberal Democrats,
is for everyone, on retirement, to receive a flat-rate pension,
regardless of their National Insurance (NI) contributions record
and other pension income. The NAPF proposes a flat £105 a week
in today's prices - 30 per cent more than the present basic
state pension - and restoration of the link between pension
increases and earnings.
Surely this is so expensive it will never
come off?
Supporters claim that this higher pension would
be paid for by scrapping additional means-tested benefits such
as the pension credit, which is costly to administer and,
basically, entitles everyone to a minimum pension of £105 a week
anyway. Further savings could be made by ditching the State
Second Pension (S2P) - formerly known as Serps.
Proponents of the citizen's pension claim the
Government would save money initially, although they concede
that reinstating the link between state pensions and earnings
would raise state pension costs over the next 20 years.
Who stands to benefit?
The basic state pension, currently just £79.60 a
week for a single person, is due to rise to £82.05 in April.
This is topped up to £105, through pension credits, for people
with no additional income (people with small savings are also
able to claim additional help through the pension credit).
A citizen's pension with the same minimum income
guarantee may not seem to benefit anyone. But it is estimated
that a quarter of those entitled to pension credit - about a
million people - fail to claim, either because they are put off
by the complexity of the process or by the stigma attached to
means-testing.
The citizen's pension will assist the estimated
8 million people who do not qualify for the full basic pension
because they do not have a full NI contributions record.
But isn't everyone entitled to a basic state
pension?
A common mistake. In order to qualify for the
full basic state pension, men need 40 years' worth of NI
contributions, and women 35 years. The TUC is calling for a
change to these rules, in particular the so-called "25 per cent
rule" - whereby retirees must have worked for long enough to
accrue at least 25 per cent of the basic state pension. Those
accruing less than this get nothing at all. Many women - who are
more likely than men to have worked for 10 years or fewer - do
not qualify for the basic state pension at all.
How soon could a citizen's pension be
introduced?
The NAPF says that it could be in place in 2010,
providing it is taken up by whichever party wins the next
election.
Is it likely to be taken up?
The Lib Dems and the Scottish National Party
already support the idea. The Conservatives are said to be
looking at it. Alan Johnson, the pensions secretary,
acknowledged in October that it "deserves closer examination"
and that he was "veering towards being positive about it". Given
the usual non-committal sounds made by ministers, this was taken
as an indication that the Department for Work and Pensions was
seriously considering it.
How would a citizen's pension affect existing
benefits?
Any existing benefits accrued through Serps or
the S2P would still be paid to those entitled to more than £105
a week. For example, someone with sufficient NI contributions to
qualify for the full basic state pension (£79.60), plus an
additional S2P of £62.00, would receive £141.60 a week, as under
the existing system.
However, someone retiring on a £55 basic state
pension, plus £20 S2P (typical sums received by many women)
would receive just the £105 citizen's pension, but not the extra
£20 S2P on top.
If the citizen's pension is introduced, then
people working will not accrue any further benefits through the
S2P.
It's not much, £105 a week. How do I get
more?
You will, of course, be able to save for a
bigger pension, through a company pension scheme or through a
private pension plan. Income from these pensions will be paid on
top of the citizen's pension.
Also, lower earners could be confident that any
additional savings would boost their retirement income. At
present, those who are only able to accumulate a modest pension
can lose out on means-tested benefits and be no better off than
if they hadn't saved at all.
This, says Alison O'Connell, a director of the
Pensions Policy Institute, is one of the main advantages of the
citizen's pension: it will provide clear incentives for all to
save; it will also give people a far clearer picture of what to
expect. Most people, now, have little idea what they will
receive from the S2P, means-tested benefits or even the basic
pension. |